The Craft of a Sustainable Economy, Part 11: Hidden Obstacles
by TODD OPPENHEIMER
While victory is sweet, the mid-term elections also raised a question for the Democrats: Will they have the courage to pass the tax reforms necessary to make life affordable for the working class—for the long term? (photo by Tom Williams, Associated Press)
In April, 2025, Jamie Raskin, a Maryland Congressman who is one of the deans of the Democratic delegation, made a rare visit to San Francisco. He had come for a small event with a young Texas colleague, Greg Casar. Although Casar had been in Congress for only two years, he had already shown such promise that, with Raskin’s support, he had just been named chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, an influential group of more than 100 members of the House of Representatives (plus one senator: Bernie Sanders).
After making a short speech of his own, Raskin shifted to introduce Casar. Over the course of his many years in Congress, Raskin said, he had learned that there are two kinds of politicians. “There are power politicians, and there are justice politicians. And it did not take long for me to realize that Rep. Casar is clearly a justice politician.”
Throughout this year, I spent a good bit of time studying many of the Democratic candidates who ran for office this cycle. As part of my work with The Patriotic Millionaires, an organization that advocates for changes in the tax code so it will stop favoring the wealthy (and stop penalizing the working class), I also helped interview dozens of these candidates. We ultimately endorsed 29 who I think could accurately be described as aspiring justice politicians. A stunning 25 of those candidates won. And they will soon find out if they can use their ideals to reform a system that has cheated and enraged voters across the country, on both the left and the right.
This past week, the Patriotic Millionaires (or the PM) held their fall conference in Washington, and I joined them–first for a day of strategizing, then a day lobbying current House and Senate members who will continue into next term. (Those who lost were all in the process of vacating their offices—a biennial ritual that put us on an odd parade past ghostly rooms, and down long hallways stacked with office chairs and empty wooden desks, all punctuated by the occasional abandoned poster and other bits of political memorabilia.)
To my surprise, given the unusually clear message that was almost screamed at members of Congress in this election, the response we got from the House and Senate members we visited was strangely mixed.
The few who had a history of going out on a limb to help the working class and fight against the advantages continually handed out to the ultra-rich, were of course excited; and, as a result, they were eager to support the PM’s ideas for leveling the economic playing field. The PM has packaged these ideas into what it calls “The Money Agenda” (subtitle: “It’s what REAL tax reform looks like.”)
The “Money Agenda” comprises three bills that we’ve spent years refining with legal experts and Congressional allies, and they’re all now shovel ready. In the summary linked above, all of these bills, plus another in formation, are defined clearly, simply, and concisely, with the reasoning behind them laid out as well. So it’s well worth taking a moment to read it.
All of these measures can be passed with a simple majority, which the Democrats now have. And one of the three has polled as voters’ top choice over 33 similar measures. Perhaps more important, this triumvirate of measures not only rebalances the tax code for the long-term, it also starts putting money into working class pockets within months of becoming law.
Despite those plusses, a good number of the party’s “moderates” we spoke with were strangely hesitant to jump on board. The various reasons we heard mostly sounded like arguments always voiced by corporate interests and wealthy citizens who are reluctant to give up the systemic advantages they’ve recently gained.
On one hand, it’s understandable that people want to keep whatever privileges they’ve won. On the other hand, isn’t this what the mid-term elections were all about? Didn’t the massive blue wave say, in big capital letters, that it’s time for our politicians to work for ALL of their constituents, not just for those often called the donor class?
There’s an odd irony at play here. While the kinds of tax-code changes needed to reduce the handicaps placed on the working class are typically promoted by the progressive left (and opposed by the right, as well as the moderates in the middle), the rationales behind these ideas are not radical. If anything, they are as American as apple pie. They derive from the original, egalitarian precepts of American capitalism, as spelled out in 1776 in Adam Smith’s famous book, “The Wealth of Nations.”
Voters clearly agreed with Smith, even if they didn’t do so consciously. That’s why they elected dozens of candidates who swore off corporate PAC money. As a result of their sacrifice, most of those brave souls were vastly outspent by competitors who did accept money from corporate and other status-quo interests. Despite the deafening message that progressive victories sent, power politicians, whether Republican or Democrat, can’t manage to kick their old habits. (The Democrats’ incessant difficulty freeing themselves from mega-donors has led one PM member to refer to their party as “the Donorcrats.”)
How in the world could this bias and blindness remain after the powerful mandate that voters handed the Democrats this month—in state after state, and in race after race? The reason, alas, goes back to Raskin’s comment about America’s two kinds of politicians.
Pardon the mini civics lesson that Raskin’s observation begs for, but the blue wave won’t bring meaningful change unless we understand a few basics about how Congress functions.
Because of the way seniority rules work on Capitol Hill, the leaders of Congress’s most important committees—especially those, like the Ways and Means Committee, that handle tax legislation—have been in Congress for years if not decades. During that time, they’ve learned that the most reliable way to survive and thrive is not to frame their work around high, egalitarian values; it’s to build the capacity to trade favors—raising money for their particular caucuses; attaching a little extra funding on one bill or another for projects in a colleague’s district; and, most of all, doing the bidding of corporate interests and other big donors so that money keeps flowing into their own campaign war chests.
These are the ingredients that create power politicians. And we can thank “Citizens United,” the 2010 Supreme Court decision that killed limits on campaign donations, for exacerbating this dynamic. As a result of that horrific ruling, Congress members are now so desperate for money that they have to spend hours and hours almost every day on fundraising.
So, when newly elected members arrive in Washington next year, they must begin with little if any political capital, because none of them have been in Congress long enough, and don’t yet have enough power, to build up deal-making credit with their colleagues. That is not to say that their cause is hopeless. Political capital to fix our broken system still exists—it’s in the hands of the voters who sent this new crop of justice politicians to Washington. This means that we voters cannot take our eye off the road, and our foot off the gas.
In the coming months, as proposals for solving today’s affordability crisis get tossed around the Capital—some landing on the top of a leader’s desk, some getting buried—we will all have to pay a little more attention than we ordinarily do to the legislative process.
If the most potent ideas don’t go anywhere, despite the Democrats’ new majority, don’t automatically blame your representative. Look first for who stopped these proposals; who watered them down beyond recognition; or who substituted fundamental reform with little bureaucratic band-aids. (Now there is a good use for AI, right?) Those band-aids include measures to restore cuts in healthcare, scientific research, and other productive programs cut by Trump and his DOGE partner, Elon Musk. They might even include a little bump up in tax rates for the wealthy. While each of those moves would be helpful for now, they would do little more than restore the half-broken system that existed before the Trump Administration stripped the economy of its last shreds of fairness.
“The system that came before Trump provided the impetus for Trump,” says Erica Payne, the Patriotic Millionaires’ founding director. “That system is bureaucratically insufficient to tackle the harms people are suffering today.” The only way to solve their problem for the long term, Payne argues, is to “restructure capitalism at its core.”
A pretty good start in that direction can be found in the ideas outlined in the PM’s Money Agenda. Although I am undoubtedly biased, plenty of Congress members seem to agree. In fact one of those who was reluctant to support the agenda’s slate of bills admitted that she had yet to see anything that is better.
See you again next month, when I will wrap this series with a select list of all the good ideas coming down the pike on how to bring American capitalism back to its founding values—of fairness and equal opportunity.
© 2026 Todd Oppenheimer. All rights reserved. Under exclusive license to Craftsmanship, LLC. Unauthorized copying or republication of any part of this article is prohibited by law.
